Appetizers

Cajun BBQ Shrimp

Cajun shrimp baked in Ruby Bloom garlic butter sauce.

$15.75

Chips & Queso

Freshly-fried blue and yellow corn tortilla chips. Warm salsa con queso for dipping.

$9.75

Flatbreads

Classic - Red sauce, Ezzo pepperoni, mushroom, and Fisher Farms Italian sausage.

Spinacotta - Red sauce, ricotta, spinach, and fontina.

Carbonara - Garlic cream sauce, bacon, Gorgonzola, and broccoli.

Create Your Own Flatbread - Choose a sauce and up to 3 toppings from our pizza menu.

$10.50

Hot Wings

Traditional Buffalo, NY-style hot sauce, House bread, celery, and bleu cheese.

$15

Basket of Fries

Choose 2: Ketchup, nacho cheese, chipotle mayo, pesto, bleu cheese, horseradish sauce, ranch, and BBQ.

$8.25

Crab Cakes

3.25 oz. pan-seared blue crab cakes with onion straws, mixed greens, mango salsa, and chipotle mayo.

1 Cake: $13.25 • 2 Cakes: $17.75

Soups & Salads

Dressings: Roasted Red Pepper Vinaigrette, Hidden Valley® Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Sesame Chili, Olive Oil & Balsamic, Italian, Poppyseed, 1000 Island, Honey-Lime Balsamic, and House (Italian with Gorgonzola crumbles).

Soup of the Day

Our house-made soups change daily.

Cup: $5.75 • Crock: $7.25

House Salad

Mixed greens, marinated red onions, carrots, tomato, pepperoncini, and toasted almonds. Can be made gluten-free.

$7.25

Gorgonzola Wedge

Sliced onion, tomato, and Gorgonzola.

$8.50

Anna’s French Onion

Caramelized onions in a rich beef broth. Topped with house-made croutons and mozzarella.

$7.75

Voodoo Chili

Thick and hearty. Spicier than most. Can be made gluten-free.

Cup: $5.75 • Crock: $7.25

Add Cheese: $1

1000 Island Wedge

Hard-boiled egg, tomato, bacon, house-made 1000 Island dressing.

$8.50

Big Bowl Salads

All dressings are served on the side. Served with Italian table bread.

~ Guest Favorite

Dressings: Roasted Red Pepper Vinaigrette, Hidden Valley® Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Sesame Chili, Olive Oil & Balsamic, Italian, Poppyseed, 1000 Island, Honey-Lime Balsamic, and House (Italian with Gorgonzola crumbles).

Cobb Salad

Roasted Miller Amish Farms chicken, bacon, Gorgonzola, egg, black olive, avocado, and red onion.

$17.75

~ Teriyaki Chicken

Marinated and grilled Miller Amish Farms chicken, mixed greens, snow peas, carrots, hard-boiled egg, cheddar, and toasted almonds. Gluten-free.

$18.25

~ Caribbean Ahi Tuna

Pepper-crusted, seared, and chilled Ahi tuna, mixed greens, mango, avocado, tomato, fried plantains, and Gorgonzola. Gluten-free.

$20.25

Turkey Tortilla

Spice-crusted turkey breast, mixed greens, corn and black bean salsa, avocado, tomato, black olives, cheddar, and crispy tortilla strips. Gluten-free.

$17.50

Wild Beet Spinach

Strawberries, beets, sugar-roasted pecans, red onions, tomato, and Caprini goat cheese.

$16.25

Add Bacon: $3 • Add Ahi Tuna: $5

Pasta

~ Guest Favorite

~ Mushroom & Chicken Tortellini

Roasted Miller Amish Farms chicken breast sautéed with fresh spinach and portobello in garlic cream sauce. Vegetarian option available.

$20.25

Spaghetti & Marinara

Spaghetti with our house-made marinara.

$15.50

Pesto Garlic Penne

Italian sausage, capicola, button mushrooms, penne, and three cheeses sautéed in pesto-garlic cream sauce. Vegetarian option available.

$19.00

Spaghetti & Meatballs

House-made Fischer Farms pork and beef meatballs simmered in rich marinara.

$17.25

Sandwiches

Served with a side of chips or cucumber slaw. Substitute fries for $2.25.

Lemon-herb tofu can be substituted for meat on any sandwich.

Our house bread is made from scratch and baked fresh daily.

~ Guest Favorite. *May also be wrapped in a flour tortilla.

~ Bacon Turkey Melt*

Roast turkey, bacon, shredded lettuce, mayo, marinated red onions, tomato, and mozzarella on house bread.

$16

~ Lennie’s Original*

Shaved roast beef, bacon, shredded lettuce, mayo, marinated red onions, tomato, and mozzarella on house bread.

$16.75

Portobello Sandwich

Grilled, marinated portobello, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, tomato, spinach, and red pepper vinaigrette on ciabatta.

$14.75

~ Reuben

Sy Ginsberg corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, and house-made 1000 Island on Jewish rye.

$17.25

Lemon Herb Tofu*

Grilled, marinated tofu, red pepper vinaigrette, lettuce, and tomato on toasted ciabatta.

$14

Red Chile Chicken*

Spice-crusted Miller Amish Farms chicken breast, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, lettuce, tomato, and chipotle mayo on toasted ciabatta.

$15.75

Roast Beef Dip

Shaved roast beef with caramelized onions and mozzarella on ciabatta with au jus.

$15.75

Gourmet Pizza

All of our pizzas are generously topped with a blend of Romano, mozzarella, and provolone.

A Love Supreme

Red sauce, Ezzo pepperoni, Fischer Farms sausage, green peppers, white onions, and mushrooms.

Small: $19.25 • Large: $24.75

The California

Pesto, spinach, black olives, sun-dried tomatoes, mozzarella, and feta. Garnished with fresh avocado.

Small: $19.50 • Large: $25

Santa Fe Chicken

BBQ sauce, roasted Miller Amish Farms chicken, cheddar, white onions, and mozzarella.

Small: $16.75 • Large: $22.25

Hoosier Harvest

Red sauce, Fischer Farms bacon, basil, grape tomatoes, Gorgonzola, and mozzarella.

Small: $18.75 • Large: $24.25

Woodsmen

Pesto, portobello and button mushrooms, oven-roasted tomatoes, and goat cheese.

Small: $18.25 • Large: $23.75

Vegan Deluxe

Red sauce, vegan cheese, green peppers, white onions, and button mushrooms with BeHive seitan pepperoni and veggie sausage on multigrain.

Small: $16.50 • Large: $22

The Big Fancy

Red sauce, ricotta, mozzarella, cheddar, and Gorgonzola.

Small: $18.50 • Large: $24

Create Your Own Pizza

Proudly serving Butcher’s Block bacon and Italian sausage, Miller Amish Farms chicken, and Ezzo pepperoni.

Step 1 - Pick Your Size

Small (10”)

6 slices.

$12

Step 2 - Pick Your Crust

Traditional

Slowly fermented and twice baked, light and crispy texture.

Multi-Grain

Heartier, made with a variety of whole grains. Vegan.

Thin

Thin and crispy. Baked on the bricks of our wood-fired oven. Available only in large.

Gluten-Free

Available only in small. Vegan.

Red

A traditional Italian pizza sauce with olive oil, seasonings, and California tomatoes. Vegan.

White

Minced garlic and EVOO. Vegan.

Pesto

Olive oil, pine nuts, garlic, basil, and Romano.

BBQ

Southwest, hickory-smoked.

Garlic Cream

Alfredo-style cream sauce.

Step 4 - Pick Your Toppings

Meats

Bacon | Baked Ham | Capicola | Hot Italian Sausage | Italian Sausage | Meatballs | Ezzo Pepperoni | Roasted Chicken | Vegan Pepperoni | Vegan Sausage

Cheeses

Cheddar | Extra Cheese | Feta | Fontina | Caprini Goat | Gorgonzola | Ricotta | Vegan Cheese

Vegetables

Artichoke Hearts | Banana Peppers | Basil | Black Olives | Button Mushrooms | Corn & Black Bean Salsa | Green Olives | Green Peppers | Jalapeños | Kalamata Olives | Oven-Roasted Portobellos | Pineapple | Red Onions (Marinated) | Red Onions (Raw) | Roasted Garlic | Roasted Red Peppers | Spinach | Sun-Dried Tomatoes | Tomato Slices | White Onions

Stromboli

All strombolis are made with Romano, provolone, and mozzarella.

Served with pickles and choice of side sauce.

Supreme

Ezzo pepperoni, Italian sausage, green peppers, white onions, and mushrooms.

$15.75

Monterey

BBQ sauce, roast chicken, jalapeños, green peppers, black olives, cheddar, and mozzarella.

$15.75

Veggie

Artichoke hearts, spinach, button mushrooms, and tomato slices.

$14.75

JM’s Favorite

Italian sausage, Ezzo pepperoni, and cheddar.

$15.50

Create Your Own

Select one of our pizza sauces and up to four ingredients from our pizza topping menu.

$16

Desserts

Ice cream sourced locally from The Chocolate Moose.

Cheesecakes

House-made NY-style cheesecakes. Tall and amazing. Selections rotate regularly.

$8.75

The Original Sin

House-made double chocolate brownie topped with locally-made vanilla bean ice cream, hot fudge, and caramel sauce.

$9.25

Mini Indulgences

Perfectly-sized not to share. Chocolate mousse or a rotating flavor.

$3.25

Root Beer Float

An old-fashioned classic. Locally-made vanilla bean ice cream and our house-made cane sugar root beer.

$7.50

Beverages

House-Made Sodas

House-made cane sugar root beer or cardamom cream soda.

$3.50

Rishi Iced Tea

$3.25

Cold Brew Coffee

Cold-brewed Brown County Roasters blend to emphasize rich roasted flavors while minimizing bitterness.

$3.25

Circle Kombucha

$5

Daytrip CBD

Sparkling flavored water.

$5